No Proof, No Sale: The Simple Rule That Could Stop Tool Theft

A new study conducted by Direct Line business insurance reveals that 67% of tradespeople support restricting the sale of second-hand tools unless sellers can prove ownership, as part of efforts to combat the growing issue of tool theft. These findings are being released ahead of the Stop Tool Theft Van Rally in Westminster on 3rd February, drawing attention to increasing concerns within the trade industry.

A survey of 500 UK tradespeople found that 70% had experienced tool theft in the past two years, with 65% believing the problem is getting worse. Additionally, 47% reported either being approached by or witnessing someone selling tools they suspected were stolen. Among these, 56% alerted the authorities, and 92% declined to purchase the items.

Stolen tools are commonly resold through social media, online marketplaces, and car boot sales. A separate poll of 2,000 UK adults revealed that 75% would not feel confident identifying stolen tools, underscoring the potential impact of requiring proof of ownership to curb the resale of stolen goods.

Where the public buys second-hand tools

Official Second-hand Goods Site - 38%

Car Boot Sale - 37%

From a Friend - 29%

Social Media - 21%

Unknown Seller/Word of Mouth - 13%

Direct Contact from a Seller - 9%

Source: Direct Line business insurance 2025

Mark Summerville, SME product manager at Direct Line business insurance, comments:

“Our research shows that the frequency of tool theft has been on the rise for several years, despite tradespeople taking additional precautions to protect their tools. So it is no surprise that 83 per cent of tradespeople are concerned about tool theft.

“While there is no silver bullet to stop tool theft, tighter rules around providing proof of purchase when selling second-hand tools could help make it harder for criminals to resell goods. It’s also important that tradespeople have adequate insurance in place to help them get back up and running, should their tools be stolen and to take precautions to protect their tools where possible.”